The 10 Best Smoker Boxes for Gas Grill in 2023

Photo: Grill Gods

Smoking the food can be more rewarding if you have the best smoker box for gas grill for your rescue. These boxes are purposely made to give direct smoke to the food, without letting the ashes get to the meals.

You don’t need a separate setup for these tools as they can easily setup in the existing gas grill. Without different sizes and materials, these give you a lot of choices to make.

However, these parameters that create variances are the ones to cause maximum bewilderment among buyers as well. But you don’t worry as this review will help in clearing a lot of concerns related to a smoker box and guide through in making a decision.

10 Best Smoker Box for Gas Grill – Review

IMAGE	PRODUCT	FEATURES
	1. Grill Gods Smoker Box (Best Overall)	1 mm thick stainless-steel construction 30% more holes Reinforced hinged lid Affordable
	2. Mockins Stainless Steel (Best Budget)	Available on best budget Lifetime warranty Easy to operate Very durable
	3. Cave Tool Smoker Box (Best Stainless-Steel Build)	Rigorous stainless-steel construction 3-cup capacity Lifetime satisfaction guarantee Comes with a recipe book
	4. Char Broil 4084804 (Best Cast Iron Construction)	Cast iron rigid construction Decently priced Suitable for most grills
	5. GrillPro 00150 (Best Small)	Small sized 8 x 5 in Cast iron durable construction Great smoky flavor Suitably priced
	6. Charcoal Companion CC4066 (Best Large)	13.78 x 4.21 in large size V-shaped smoker Sturdy construction Easy to use
	7. Weber 7576 (Best Flat Bottom Design)	Compatible with most grills Differently shaped vents and holes Easy to operate Durable construction
	8. Charcoal Companion CC4057 (Best V-Shaped Box)	Decently sized V-shaped box Non-stick construction Most intense smoky flavor Very durable
	9. Cave Tool Smoker Box LG (Best Warranty)	Comes with superior warranty Robust construction 3-cup capacity Suitable pricing
	10. Grillaholics Stainless Steel (Standard Design)	Multiple vents for even smoking Easy access Extra thick stainless-steel Lightweight

1. Grill Gods Smoker Box – Best Overall

Photo: Grill Gods

• Size: 9.2 x 3.5 inches
• Material: Stainless Steel
• Shape: Flat Bottom

What makes this box the best overall product is its exceptionally durable construction with 1-millimeter stainless steel material that will last the longest and stay away from warping.

There are various other factors that add to the glory of this model. Unlike other products, it has 30% more holes and vents to offer maximum smoking.

This flat-bottom freestanding box is suitable for all kinds of gas grills and won’t consume a lot of space either. You can simply put it inside the barbeque and allow it to work its magic.

The capacity of this model is decent and it can work for hours to keep your food perfectly smoked, even if you have to wait for the guests to arrive.

The reinforced hinged lid makes accessibility incredibly simple. It is easy to open and even if you have to add more wood to the box, there won’t be any hassle.

This model is pretty affordable and the company takes full guarantee of any grievances that customers might have. On the downside, the sheen and color of the box might fade out after recurring usage.

Pros:

• Thick stainless-steel construction
• Affordable
• Easy to use
• Decent capacity

Cons:

• Color and shine might fade out

2. Mockins Stainless Steel – Best Budget

Photo: Mockins

• Size: 8.8 x 3.5 inches
• Material: Stainless Steel
• Shape: Flat Bottom

For the budget buyers, there is no better option than the Mockins Stainless-Steel smoker box. It gives you great value of money from its robust construction. The 430 stainless-steel material is used in the construction that can take the beating of its rigorous use.

Other than that, it is available in a decent size of 8.8 x 3.5 inches and will accommodate sufficient wood to serve a small BBQ gather at your place.

What makes it more likable is the easy accessibility. The lid is firm yet easy to operate in the harshest conditions. Even when you have to refill the box, the lid will open on a single push and make your job simpler than ever.

The brand surely seeks confidence from its creation that they are willing to give lifetime warranty on this model.

Well, there are a few sad parts like the holes on the box are too small to let the smoke come out freely. It will take time to smoke the food. Also, because of the lack of non-stick coating, you might find it difficult to clean.

Pros:

• Available on most affordable price
• Lifetime warranty
• Decently sized
• Easy accessibility

Cons:

• No non-stick coating
• Very less holes on the box

3. Cave Tool Smoker Box – Best Stainless-steel

Photo: Cave Tool

• Size: 9 x 3 inches
• Material: Stainless Steel
• Shape: Flat Bottom

The high-end stainless-steel construction of this model makes it different from other competitive smoker boxes. It comes with 25% thicker stainless-steel that will abolish the concept of warping from this box.

This is a standard sized flat-bottom box with the highest capacity of 3-cups wood in it. The holes are curated in a symmetrical manner to even smoke the food.

It has a slim profile and a very delectable appeal to impress the buyers. What makes it more special is the lifetime guarantee that the company is willing to offer.

Also, you get a recipe book with this model with 25 professional barbeque recipes in it. The lid however, is a bit difficult to open that might cause trouble when the box is hot and you need to refill.

Pros:

• Stainless-steel robust construction
• Delectable appeal
• Comes with lifetime guarantee
• Even smoking of the food

Cons:

• The lid is a bit difficult to open

4. Char Broil 4084804 – Best Cast Iron Smoker Box

Photo: Char Broil

• Size: 8.12 x 5.13 inches
• Material: Cast Iron
• Shape: Flat Bottom

If you have your heart set on a cast iron smoker box then this is your best bet. It is constructed with high-quality cast iron material, extremely promising in quality and the performance is also pretty amazing.

This model is decently sized in 8.12 x 5.13-inches, making it suitable for most of the gas grills. You just have to place it in the barbeque area and this will handle rest of the task.

The wood holding capacity of this model is also decent as it has more depth than length and will hold up to 3 cups of wood. The price of this model is pretty decent and you get a lot in return.

The vents however are a bit larger and they might flame the food if kept too close to the smoker box. So, you should be a bit careful while placing food in the BBQ. Also, it is a bit heavyweight than its peers and weighs 4.2-pounds.

Pros:

• Rigid cast iron construction
• Easy to use
• Decent capacity
• Affordable price

Cons:

• A bit heavyweight
• Large vents might burn the food

5. GrillPro 00150 – Best Small Smoker Box

Photo: GrillPro

• Size: 8 x 5 inches
• Material: Cast Iron
• Shape: Flat Bottom

Well, if you cannot spare a lot of space in the grill then this compact model with 8 x 5-inches dimensions will be perfectly suitable. This model has got everything you want from a high-performance smoker box.

So, the construction is done with cast iron material that definitely bring the durability factor in the picture. It has rigid body and very promising construction.

The wood holding capacity of this model is also decent and you get great smoky flavor from the food. The lid is easy to remove which increases the usability and functionality of this model a lot.

It is suitably priced and has incredible looks as well. On the downside, you might find it difficult to clean and it does not come with any warranty as well.

Pros:

• Compact and easily fitting
• High performance box
• Easy to use
• Decent wood holding capacity

Cons:

• Difficult to clean
• No warranty

6. Charcoal Companion CC4066 – Best Large Smoker Box

Photo: Charcoal Companion

• Size: 13.78 x 4.21 inches
• Material: Stainless Steel
• Shape: V-Shaped

Well, if you have a large grill and you like your food to be smoked for long hours then this model can be a suitable pick. It is the best large smoker box for gas grill with overall dimensions of 13.78 x 4.21-inches.

It is a durable model, made with high-quality stainless steel. Since it is V-shaped, you can adjust it between flame deflector bars and allow it to work. There are plenty of holes on the top to offer uniform smoking. Also, these are small in size to not allow the flames to come out.

The usage of this model is quite simple and once you have added wooden chips in it, this won’t require multiple refills. The ashes also stay inside the box and keep the grill clean.

Unfortunately, you might find the lid too stubborn to open when you need it to. Other than that, this is quite suitable model.

Pros:

• Large in size
• Durable
• Easy to fit

Cons:

• Lid is a bit difficult to open

7. Weber 7576 – Best Flat Bottom Smoker Box

Photo: Weber

• Size: 9.7 x 4.7 inches
• Material: Stainless Steel
• Shape: Flat Bottom

This one has high compatibility and a very sturdy stainless-steel design to easily fit inside differently sized gas grills. It does not need any deflector to adjust but the freestanding design will make its peace with all the grills.

Another very impressive feature of this model is the differently designed vents and holes to smoke your food in the most effective way. You can also operate the box with utmost ease and convenience.

You can add the wooden chips once inside the box and it is good to serve for the longest time. The durability is extremely promising and this is a highly functional product. The only sad thing about it is the lack of warranty.

Pros:

• Sturdy and firm flat bottom box
• Durable
• Decently sized
• Easy to use

Cons:

• No warranty

8. Charcoal Companion CC4057 – Best V-Shaped Smoker Box

Photo: Charcoal Companion

• Size: 13.75 x 4 inches
• Shape: V-Shaped

Many people prefer V-shaped smoker box over a flat bottom. Well, if you are one of them then try this Charcoal Companion CC4057 smoker box constructed with metal and have non-stick coating on the top to enhance performance and make it super easy to clean.

The product fits most of the grill deflectors and won’t give you hard time in offering uniform smokiness in the grill through the multiple holes on the top.

It is very promising in performance and offer most intense smoky flavor in the food. The construction is durable and the product will be able to take the test of time.

The only drawback is that the color on the top might start to fade off after continual usage.

Pros:

• Best V-shaped smoker box
• Uniform smoking of food
• Easy to operate
• Non-stick coating

Cons:

• Color might fade after some time

9. Cave Tool Smoker Box LG – Best Warranty Smoker Box

Photo: Cave Tool

• Size: 9 x 5.1 inches
• Material: Stainless Steel
• Shape: Flat Bottom

This model offers a lot of buying confidence to the buyers as it comes with lifetime satisfaction guarantee. Throughout the life, if anything goes wrong with this product, you get an exchange model or moneyback, however it suits you.

The decently sized model can accommodate 3-cups of wood chips. It is easy to use and the hinged lid will stay firm while lending you the convenience of using the box.

Furthermore, you get the robustness of stainless-steel construction that helps in increasing the life of the box. It is suitably priced and practically one of the best smoker attachments for grill.

The only drawback is the lack of non-stick coating that can make cleaning a bit of a task.

Pros:

• Comes with best warranty
• Suitably priced
• Decent capacity
• Great performance

Cons:

• Cleaning could be difficult

10. Grillaholics Stainless Steel – Standard Smoker Box for Gas Grill

Photo: Grillaholics

• Size: 8.75 x 3.75 inches
• Material: Stainless Steel
• Shape: Flat Bottom

There are multiple vents on this box, including the lid and the box that offer maximum efficiency in smoking food from all sides. This is one of the most efficient smoker boxes on the list.

The durability of the product is ensured with extra thick stainless-steel layering which helps in prevent warping to a major extent.

This flat bottom design box will sit inside the grill comfortably and do its job with perfection. The 0.95-pounds of overall weight makes it easy to transport and use. Also, the hinged lid makes the access simpler than ever.

The cleaning could be a bit competitive because of the lack of non-stick coating. Plus, the lack of warranty might also miss the interest of some potential buyers. But overall, this product is of decent quality.

Pros:

• Multiple vents for more efficiency
• Durable
• Lightweight

Cons:

• No warranty
• Difficult to clean

How to Buy the Best Smoker Box for Gas Grill

Photo: Charcoal Companion

1. Size and Capacity

The main concern of every buyer is to find a size fitting to the grill’s size. Plus, it should be able to take sufficient capacity of wood so that you don’t have to add more wood frequently to it.

So, what you got to do is to determine the grill’s size and the amount of smoke you want to produce. At the same time, you need to ensure how much wood can a box hold. Some of the best ones like the Cave Tool Smoker Box LG can hold a maximum of 3-cups of wood at one time.

With this model, you don’t have to disrupt the process for adding more fuel to the box. If you are planning to smoke something for several hours then always check for smoker box with high capacity. If not then you can live with a smaller box as well.

2. Material

Please note that a smoker box is in direct contact with the flaming hot wood. You cannot make a mistake while selecting the material because it will largely influence the durability of the product.

There are two most popular materials in smoker box – cast iron and stainless-steel. The later is considered as the best choice for most people because of its amazing features. However, the former is better on durability. Let’s take a look at these both with some competitive parameters.

Durability

While the toughness of both the materials, stainless steel and cast iron is almost at the same edge, there is some difference because of the warping issue.

When steel is constant exposed to high temperatures, it warps quicker than cast iron. However, manufacturers have come up with a solution of giving multiple layers of steel to the box to prevent warping.

Appearance

If you have people to impress with the appearance of the tools then stainless steel is your companion. It looks glossy and beautiful and will impress most spectators. Cast iron on the other hand does not have sheen and looks dull.

Heating Tendency

Cast iron has high volumetric heat capacity which takes time for this material to heat-up. Stainless-steel on the other hand heats up faster and saves your time.

Therefore, if you want to prepare food quickly then stainless-steel should be the choice in material. On the other hand, cast iron will be useful when you have to keep the food on heat for a long time.

There is no winner here. You should select based on your needs as both the materials are great in different aspects.

3. Design & Shape

There are three designs available in best gas grill smoker box – V-shaped, W-shaped, and flat bottom. The difference of shape does not impact the performance of the product. It is simply to give more shape-related choice to the users.

One thing that is extremely essential during the selection process is to see if a particular design and shape is compatible with your gas grill.

The V-shaped and W-shaped needs adjustment in the grill area but the flat bottom ones are free-standing and they don’t need any special adjustment inside the BBQ area. You can get the benefit of sleek designing and compatibility with differently sized gas grills in the Weber 7576 that comes in flat-bottom design.

4. Non-Stick Coating

The non-stick coating is not compulsory in all the models. However, this coating makes cleaning job extremely simple and comfortable. Moreover, all the best smoker trays for gas grills usually have non-stick coating.

How To Use A Smoker Box

Photo: Cave Tools

The process of using a smoker box is pretty straightforward. Let’s see:

• You should start by placing the smoker box on the grill and allow it to heat as the barbeque heats.
• Using kitchen tongs and with complete cautiously, remove or turn the lid. Make sure when you place the box to unhinge the box’s lid.
• Its time to insert the wooden chips in the box. Make sure the wood you are adding is completely dry to create best smoke. If the wood is soaked, it will take more time and might not smoke as well also. Make sure to add sufficient wood so that you can get through the entire cooking process.
• Cover the box with the lid and then close the grill’s lid as well. This is when the wood will flame and start to create smoke.
• Give it some time so that the temperature inside could rise and wait till you can see some smoke before opening the grill’s lid again.
• As soon as you see sufficient smoke, open the lid and place your meat inside. Give it some time (as long as you want to smoke the meat) and enjoy the flavorful meat.

Conclusion

On closing the smoker box for gas grill review, all we want to say is that if you are extremely fond of grilling and like your meat to be perfectly smoked then you wouldn’t want to go wrong with this purchase.

The Grill Gods Smoker Box definitely wins all the brownie points with its extremely durable construction, equal distribution of vents and holes for unobstructed supply of smoke, without flaming the meat.

If you are fonder of cast iron smoker box for gas grill then your best bet will be the Char Broil 4084804. It is extremely durable and gives you the performance of lifetime.

Happy Shopping!