7 Best Pizza Peels of 2023

Photo: Heritage Products

In the recent past, pizza was transferred from the oven using gloves or hands. However, in the modern day, it is safe and efficient to lift pizza using a pizza peel.

A pizza peel is a great kitchen addition as it is also used to lift cupcakes, muffin, bread or cakes from the oven. Hence, this is an item that comes with multiple functions.

For superior quality and durability, you need to buy the best pizza peel available. It should have a smooth surface and easy to clean and maintain.

If you want to buy a high-quality pizza peel, here is a detailed guide and 7 genuine pizza peel reviews to help you spot the best.

7 Best Pizza Peels – Review

IMAGE	​PRODUCT	​FEATURES
	1. Pizza Royale Pizza Peel (Best for Mini Pizzas)	Small size for mini pizzas Easy grip handle for comfort Anti-microbial bamboo material Unique design that does not chip or warp
	2. American Metalcraft 3714 (Best for Large Pizza)	Large size for large pizza Superior quality aluminum material Smooth surface for easy pizza lifting Different handle lengths
	3. Heritage Products SYNCHKG125894 (Best All Wood Pizza Peel)	High quality acacia wood material Smooth surface for easy lifting Tapered edges for swooping pizza
	4. Checkered Chef 751570952410 (Comfortable Grip)	Rubber handle gives comfortable grip Quality stainless steel construction Dishwasher safer makes it easy to clean Multiple uses
	5. Chef Pomodoro COMINHKPR136940 (Foldable)	Foldable design makes it compact Commercial grade aluminum material Natural pine wooden handle Easy to maintain and dry
	6. New Star Foodservice 50158 (Keeps Safe from Oven Heat)	Long wooden handle keeps your hands away from oven heat Anodized aluminum material Triple-riveted handle Tapered edges
	7. Honey-Can-Do 4439 (Low Maintenance Work)	Low maintenance as it is easy to clean High quality aluminum material Heat resistant wooden handle Lightweight design for easy movement

1. Pizza Royale Pizza Peel – Best for Mini Pizzas

Photo: Pizza Royale

• Size: 19.6 x 0.6 x 12 Inches
• Material: Bamboo Wood

Pizza Royal pizza peel is one of the few super quality pizza peels available in small sizes hence, it ideally makes mini pizzas, making it perfect for use in home baking ovens.

This product has an easy grip handle that makes it a breeze to hold the product even after being topped with bought or home-made pizza. The handle is even contoured to give you a firm grip and ensure that it will not slide while on use.

The reason why this is the best pizza peel on the market is that it features an antimicrobial and eco-friendly bamboo material, implying that it naturally prohibits bacterial growth on it, keeping you and your loved ones healthy.

Ideally, this product comes with 180 days money-back guarantee and this plays a great role in boosting your confidence in it. Therefore, you can be sure that it will either give you satisfaction or you get your money back in a painless process.

Additionally, this pizza peel comes with a unique design that ensures that it will not chip, warp or split. This implies that the product’s surface remains smooth for a prolonged period of time without any deformations.

Pros:

• Made of high-quality material with exception durability and quality
• Its surface is perfectly sized for home ovens
• Satisfaction guaranteed – 180 days money back guarantee
• Firm and comfortable grip

Cons:

• Unsuitable for those who need a larger size
• Handle is not very long so people with big oven have to reach deep for it

2. American Metalcraft 3714 – Best for Large Pizza

Photo: American Metalcraft

• Size: 39 x 10 x 10 Inches
• Material: Aluminum

Here is the pizza peel that you should buy for making large sized pizza as it has a large size. Hence, with this product, you can prepare a pizza that is large enough for your family and friends. 

Additionally, the American Metalcraft is the best metal pizza peel because it features a superior quality aluminum material and so it is highly durable, giving you perfect value for your money.

Moreover, it is also very light this allows you to easily carry a large pizza without experiencing a lot of fatigue.

The smooth surface that comes with this pizza peel makes it effortless for you to slide, rotate and remove the pizza from the oven.

Additionally, to make this product more ergonomic, it comes with four different handle lengths, giving you options to choose from and becomes safer for your hands.

American Metalcraft pizza peel also has an authentic and more rustic presentation for serving. In addition, this also polishes the look of your kitchen upgrading its feel and appearance. Nonetheless, it might be hard to store this product in limited spaces due to its long handle.

Pros:

• Different handle lengths to choose from
• Superior durability for long-lasting service
• Lightweight due to its aluminum material
• Smooth surface for effortless lifting

Cons:

• Might not fit in limited spaces due to long handles
• Has sharp edges where the handle connects with the aluminum plate

3. Heritage Products SYNCHKG125894 – Best All-Wood Pizza Peel

Photo: Heritage Products

• Size: 22.1 x 14.4 x 0.9 Inches
• Material: Acacia Wood

Heritage Products pizza peel is the best all wood pizza peel because it comes with all good qualities that you can get from a wooden pizza peel. This implies that it is highly functional when cooking and also is a great addition to your kitchen aesthetics because of its attractiveness.

One of the great things you will first notice about this pizza peel is its smooth surface. This is mainly because it features the highest quality wood material, which is also sanded and crafted. Hence, pizza effortlessly slides on it while transferring it on the pizza stone when cooking.

In addition, it also features tapered edges which allow you to swoop up pizza or bread from the oven with a lot of simplicity. However, since this product features wood material, it needs careful maintenance like perfectly drying it after each use to enhance its durability.

Pros:

• Looks beautiful and elegant
• Perfectly sized too cook pizza and fit compactly in the oven
• Handle remains cool keeping your hands safe

Cons:

• Needs proper maintenance during and after cleaning

4. Checkered Chef 751570952410 – Comfortable Grip

Photo: Checkered Chef

• Size: 2 x 15.9 x 9.8 Inches
• Material: Stainless Steel

This is a pizza peel that features a firm and comfortable grip, making the product highly ergonomic. Mainly, this is facilitated by the rubber handle the product comes with. As a result, the handle is non-slip and non-scratchy.

Additionally, it comes with superior quality and durability. This is promoted by the premium quality stainless steel construction it comes with.

With the stainless steel construction of this pizza peel, it is very easy to clean the product after every use as it is dishwasher safe. Therefore, you can effortlessly clean it after each use.

This is the best pizza peel because it features multi-purpose use. As a result, you can use it to handle numerous tasks on the market and this way, it gives you amazing value while saving you a lot of money in the long run.

Pros:

• Easy to store as it features space saving design
• Comfortable grip
• Easy to clean-dishwasher safe
• Great quality and multiple uses

Cons:

• Unsuitable for making a very large pizza

5. Chef Pomodoro COMINHKPR136940 – Foldable

Photo: Chef Pomodoro

• Size: 25 x 14 x 1 Inches
• Material: Aluminum

Chef Pomodoro pizza peel features a foldable design that allows you to easily store it in limited spaces. As a result, it is perfect for kitchens with limited spaces and so it can fit in kitchens within a house, condo, restaurant or apartment.

This is the because it is made using commercial grade aluminum material which heats up fast and also the best metal pizza peel makes the product lightweight. The material is highly durable and so it will serve you for a long period.

The handle of this pizza peel is made using a natural pine wood that is heat-resistant. This way, your hands are well protected against burns when removing pizza from the oven. Additionally, this handle is also foldable, giving the product a compact design for easy transportation and storage.

If you are looking for a pizza peel that is easy to maintain and dry, this is the product you should invest in. Its aluminum material requires low maintenance as all you need to do is clean it with warm soapy water then hang it to dry. 

Pros:

• Durable and efficient due to high-quality material
• Elegant appearance from the wooden handle
• Lightweight and compact enhances movement
• Heat resistant wooden handle

Cons:

• Not dishwasher friendly but easy to clean
• Handle not tightly screwed

6. New Star Foodservice 50158 – Keeps Safe from Oven Heat

Photo: New Star Foodservice

• Size: 33 x 16 x 1 Inches
• Material: Anodized Aluminum

This product has been designed with a long wooden handle that keeps your hands safe from oven heat. Hence, you will no longer drop pies or burn your arms since this pizza peel protects you, making it safe.

Most people refer to this product as the best pizza peel for home use because it comes with different lengths and sizes. As a result, it presents you with numerous options to pick from depending on the size of your family or the number of people you intend to serve.

In addition, the quality of this product is second to none as it features the top quality anodized aluminum material for the plate. This implies that it heats up easily and also comes with a lightweight design. Hence, you can easily lift it up even with large pizza on it.

New Star Foodservice Pizza Peel is triple-riveted at the handle to give you a sure and firm grip. Its handle is wooden and this implies that the product will always be cool regardless of the high temperatures in the oven.

Moreover, this is a product that has been designed with tapered edges in order to make sure that it can easily slip under the pizza when lifting it from the oven. Nonetheless, this product is not dishwasher safe, but it is easy to clean and dry with your hands.

Pros:

• Easily slides under the pizza
• Keeps your hands safe
• Different lengths and sizes available
• Firm and sure grip

Cons:

• Not dishwasher safe
• A little big for storage in tight spaces

7. Honey-Can-Do 4439 – Low Maintenance Work

Photo: Honey-Can-Do

• Size: 18 x 16 x 1.2 Inches
• Material: Aluminum

Here is a pizza peel that features low maintenance work as it is easy to clean and dry after every use. All you need to do is clean it using warm soapy water and that is all hence, this product is fit for daily use as it does not demand lots of maintenance work.  

This is the best pizza peel on the market because it makes perfect crisp outer pizza crust than any other product mainly because it is made using aluminum material that easily conducts heat, creating an outer crust that you will always enjoy.

Moreover, its handle is made using wood and this implies that it is heat-resistant and so it keeps your hands safe from accidental burns. In addition, the handle is long enough to keep your hands away from the oven heat. It also comes with a comfortable grip, making it more user-friendly.

This pizza peel is lightweight and this makes it easy for you to move around in the kitchen with pizza on it. Nonetheless, it does not have a hole on the handle for hanging purposes.

Pros:

• Keeps you from oven heat due to a long handle
• Added stability from the reinforced handle
• Heats up fast due to the aluminum material
• Easy to clean and dry

Cons:

• No hanging hole on the handle for drying proposes
• Outer edge has sharp nicks hence care is required when handling

How to Buy the Best Pizza Peel

Photo: Checkered Chef

1. Size

This is a critical factor that you must consider when buying a valuable pizza peel. Mainly, this is because different products feature different sizes.

Therefore, to make sure that you buy a perfect size for your needs, you should consider the size of your oven, the number of people you intend to serve and the size of pizza you intend to cook.  

2. Handle

One of the important things that you should check out for when buying a pizza peel is the length of the handle. In case the handle is short, then there is a possibility that you will suffer avoidable burns when reaching deep into the oven.

A very long handle, on the other hand, has a storage challenge because it cannot fit in limited spaces when not in use. Moreover, if you find a pizza peel with a foldable handle, then this will be a great purchase, as it boosts convenient storage and high portability.

When it comes to the best handle material of a pizza peel, it is wise to go for a product that features a heat-resistant handle like wood. This implies that the handle will remain cool while cooking and this keeps your hands safe from accidental burns in the kitchen.

3. Material

Pizza peels are either made of metal or wood. The best one for you is determined by features you are in search of and your personal preference between these two materials. Each one of them has individual strengths and weakness, hence, you should go for the one that gives you value.

Wood

These are pizza peels that are aesthetically appealing, traditional and elegant. This means that you can serve pizza to your guests on wooden pizza peels with no embarrassment as they are beautiful and presentable.

Nonetheless, a pizza peel made of wood requires proper maintenance as you cannot store them unless they are completely dry after cleaning. Moreover, you need to clean then using your hands as most of them are not dishwasher friendly.

Metallic

These are products that feature a sleek design, and they are quite easy to slide under the pizza. Additionally, they are easy to clean and dry implying that they are easy to maintain. Nonetheless, you should avoid using harsh detergents when cleaning them.

In most cases, metallic pizza peels are beginner-friendly as they feature a highly ergonomic design, which does not require any skills to use them. In addition, metallic pizza peels are lightweight enhancing durability.

However, you should be careful when using them as some of them have sharp edges that can cut you.

4. Design

The paddle can feature different shapes and this determines the simplicity of transferring or swooping pizza from the oven. In most cases, you will find rectangular or round shaped paddles. You should consider buying one that matches the shape of your oven and your taste as well.

Additionally, if you go for a wooden pizza peel, the edges should be slanted or tapered as this makes it simple for you to slide it under the pizza.     

Conclusion

There is a lot of significance in buying yourself a reliable pizza peel. This is because it is a great addition in any kitchen and so it should give you great value and service for a prolonged period of time.

After assessing your needs and features that you require in a pizza peel, this guide and pizza peel reviews will definitely help you arrive at your best option in a timely manner and without wasting money or much effort. Order the best product that will give you value for your cash.